In India, two events consistently spark intense media coverage about jobs: the release of government recruitment application numbers and slight changes in the official unemployment rate. Both miss the core issue: India faces a wages problem, not a jobs problem. With an official unemployment rate of 5%, anyone who wants a job can find one, but the wages often fall short of expectations. High-paying private sector job creation is being undermined by three wage-related fault lines: Government vs Private, Nominal vs Real, and Gross vs Net wages.
Government vs Private Wages
The wage disparity between government and private sector jobs in India is stark. Senior government officials are underpaid, while lower-level government employees are overpaid compared to their private sector counterparts. This imbalance distorts the labor market, with lower-level government employees earning more than 200% of what similar private sector roles offer, excluding the added job security and minimal performance accountability. This discrepancy drives the overwhelming number of applicants for government jobs, not because private sector jobs are less secure or lower-paying, but because government jobs offer significantly higher pay and job security. Ideally, government employment should be about public service with fair wages, rather than a distorted market rate.
Nominal vs Real Wages
Migration to urban areas is crucial for economic growth but is hindered by the high cost of living in India’s major cities. The exorbitant price of land directly impacts living, eating, and commuting expenses, slowing down migration to job-rich areas. India has only 50 cities with populations exceeding one million, compared to China’s 375. Economic centers like Mumbai, Delhi, and Chandigarh struggle to compete with emerging job hubs like Gachibowli, Mohali, Gurgaon, and Bangalore, where mixed-use real estate is more readily available. Reducing commuting times and improving urban infrastructure could significantly boost job satisfaction and productivity.
Gross vs Net Wages
In the current salary structure, a monthly gross salary of Rs 15,000 often translates to a net bank credit of Rs 8,000 due to mandatory deductions for schemes like Provident Fund, ESI, LWF, and EPS. Workers earning Rs 1.8 lakh annually, according to government data, have no savings and cannot sustain themselves on half their gross salary. Consequently, many prefer informal sector jobs where the take-home pay equals the gross pay, avoiding these deductions.
Regulatory Interventions Needed
These wage discrepancies stifle the growth of high-paying formal private jobs. To address this, three key regulatory interventions are necessary: Faster Urbanization, Lower Regulatory Hurdles, and Broader Human Capital Development.
- Faster Urbanisation: Increase the number of Indian cities with populations over a million from 50 to 200. High-quality urbanization, with robust city governance and finances, can create a cycle of higher formalization, productivity, and wages. Reducing land prices and accelerating construction through initiatives like demonetization can enhance labor mobility.
- Lower Regulatory Hurdles: Simplify job creation by reducing the regulatory burden. With 6.3 crore enterprises in India, only 18,000 have paid-up capital exceeding Rs 10 crore. Streamlining regulations can help low-productivity enterprises grow and afford higher wages.
- Broader Human Capital Development: Focus on improving primary education, as the new job market increasingly values skills in reading, writing, arithmetic, and soft skills. Better education will equip the workforce for higher productivity roles.
Immediate Actions for the Ministry of Labour
While long-term plans for urbanization and human capital development take effect, the Ministry of Labour should implement three immediate interventions:
- Universal Enterprise Number: Replace the current 27 different identification numbers issued to employers with a single, universal number.
- Digital Compliance: Set a target for 100% digital compliance with labor laws, eliminating corruption and reducing paperwork.
- Provident Fund and ESI Reforms: Make employee contributions to the Provident Fund voluntary and introduce competition for ESI and EPFO by allowing alternatives like NPS and Health Insurance.
The recent youth unrest in India is rooted in a lack of formal job opportunities. Addressing these wage fault lines and implementing the suggested reforms can significantly improve the job market and overall economic health. As Mahatma Gandhi once said, the difference between what we do and what we are capable of doing can solve our problems – a timely reminder for the Ministry of Labour.
Reference:
